It's next to impossible to go undefeated in a college basketball season, and few pundits were expecting the Syracuse Orange to roll through the 16-team Big East without a single blemish on their ledger sheet. With that having been said, nobody saw this Saturday's stunner at the Carrier Dome, with the exception of the Pittsburgh Panthers.
And even they had to wonder if they could stroll into upstate New York and hand Jim Boeheim his first loss in 14 games.
Just how fragile was Pitt heading into its first game of 2010? The Panthers owned an 11-2 record, but that mark was built almost entirely on cupcakes. Coach Jamie Dixon's team scored a solid 68-55 win over Wichita State on Nov. 23, and that 13-point pasting of a Missouri Valley Conference contender represented the best thing Pitt had done up to this point in its campaign. Victories over Duquesne and Wofford were nothing to sneeze at, but the point remained that the Panthers were a far cry from last season's squad, a loaded ballclub that reached the Elite Eight and narrowly lost to Villanova in the East Regional Final.
Pitt dropped its biggest showdown to Texas on Nov. 24, an entirely expected result for a team that's retooling. However, a Dec. 8 loss to Indiana in New York indicated just how much of a drop-off the Panthers had to contend with. As they made the trip to Syracuse, the boys from Western Pennsylvania couldn't have felt too confident about their prospects. No longer equipped with the terrific triumvirate of guard Levance Fields, forward Sam Young, and space-eating, rebound-gobbling center DeJuan Blair, a smaller and less proven Pittsburgh outfit had to take on an Orange outfit that knocked around North Carolina, clobbered California, and foiled Florida.
The numbers didn't add up for Pitt against the No. 5 team in the United States... at least, not in the pregame shootaround.
But oh, how Dixon's defense changed perceptions under the big top.
Pitt's defense was tenacious from start to finish, particularly on the perimeter. A Syracuse team that loves to get out in transition and use its open-court athleticism was summarily smothered by the prowling Panthers. The Orange went just 1 of 13 from 3-point range, as long-range specialist Andy Rautins was limited to just one made triple in six attempts. Pitt committed 18 turnovers and allowed 14 more shot attempts, but because of their defense against Rautins and his fellow backcourt mate, Brandon Triche (2 of 9 for just 6 points), the Panthers were able to dictate tempo for 40 minutes. With Panther guards Ashton Gibbs (6 of 9 on 3-pointers, 24 points) and Jermaine Dixon (7 of 16 field goals, 21 points) repeatedly knocking down shots, the visitors from the Steel City found the scoring punch needed to prevail.
The Big East season has already been a wild one. Who knows how bumpy the ride will be for Syracuse after this unexpected loss? Just as intriguing is this other question: How much can the Pittsburgh Panthers continue to improve?