It’s hard to reach narrow, finite verdicts on the Big East, given the sprawling nature of the 16-team conference. A mixture of positive and negative stories is likely to define just about any night in which at least four or more league games are played. There are multiple sections of the Big East on display every night, various "neighborhoods" in which different amounts of rent are paid.
In the low-rent section of the Big East, good news emerged as South Florida - consistently a doormat - shed its loser label by springing a 15-point upset against heralded Cleveland State in the Horizon League. The Bulls aren't about to become a top tier team, as shown by their loss to Southern Mississippi later in the week. However, they're showing a level of competitiveness which hasn't always existed on the hardwood in Tampa. Providence thumped Rhode Island, winning an in-state battle with a somewhat surprising level of ease. Rhode Island has been a bubble team in recent seasons, so the ability of Providence to hand out a beatdown is a definite source of encouragement for the Friars.
In the upper-middle class section of the Big East, the news was mostly bad. Georgetown did score a win over Memphis - its second of the year against the Tigers - but the value of that win was overshadowed by two shocking losses. Marquette, one of the league's 11 tournament teams last season and a Sweet 16 party crasher, was shocked on the road by LSU, a downmarket team in the Southeastern Conference. The Golden Eagles usually do live on the edge, but even they figured to win against a program known for its football, not its basketball. Yet, as bad as that loss was for the Big East as a whole, Pittsburgh suffered an even greater embarrassment on Friday. The Panthers, playing at home against a small-conference foe, figured to notch an easy win against the Wagner Seahawks of the Northeast Conference. Instead, Pitt - a number one seed last year and a nationally-ranked club when it took the floor on Dec. 23 - fell to coach Danny Hurley's club, committing 18 turnovers and failing to maintain any sense of composure in its halfcourt offense. Pittsburgh became discombobulated against Wagner's defensive pressure and could never get on the beam as the 40-minute nightmare unfolded.
In the posh high-rent district, everything remained harmonious. Louisville and Syracuse, holding down two of the top four spots in the national rankings, continued their winning ways to remain unbeaten for the season. Now that Big East play is beginning, some losses are certainly likely, but the Cardinals and Orange are still in position to lock down high seeds for the 2012 NCAA Tournament.